Virtue, EIIR and Tolkien

James Paul  |  Features  |  culture watch
Date posted:  1 Nov 2022
Share Add       
Virtue, EIIR and Tolkien

Sophia Nomvete portrays the dwarf-princess Disa | photo: Ben Rothstein/Prime Video

Two very different events this past month have led me to reflect on the continuing relevance of moral philosopher Alasdair MacIntyre’s prophetic work After Virtue (Duckworth, 1981).

MacIntyre explains how the West has moved from a culture based around the practice of virtues, to one in which moral judgments are merely expressions of personal feelings and attitudes, often used to produce similar feelings in others. Nowhere has this change been more demonstrated than in the death of her late Majesty Queen Elizabeth II.

As the Queen’s 96-year life was reviewed on TV and in print, what became abundantly clear is that she was a woman of virtue. The virtues, as MacIntyre defines them, are those dispositions which enable us to overcome the harms, dangers, temptations and distractions we encounter, and flourish in our understanding and practice of what is truly good. The path of virtue is not just about reaching a goal but about how we live moment-by-moment in a broken world.

Share
< Previous article| Features| Next article >
Read more articles on:   culture
Read more articles by James Paul >>
Features
Minutely-controlled world

Minutely-controlled world

It might seem strange that after watching over two and a half hours of Cate Blanchett’s riveting performance as fictional …

Features
A Christ-like Pinocchio?

A Christ-like Pinocchio?

‘What does it mean to be human?’ and ‘What makes a good life?’ are two key questions which all cultures, …

Subscribe

Enjoy our monthly paper and full online access

Find out more

Give a subscription

🎁 Get 20% off a subscription for a friend this Christmas!

Tell me more