The Christmas census

Chris Sinkinson  |  Features  |  defending our faith
Date posted:  1 Dec 2012
Share Add       

The gospel stands on historical credentials. David Jackman helpfully demonstrates this in his column this month.

Objections to the Christmas story come from many quarters. Sometimes these objections make fair points. Jesus was almost certainly not born in a barn on December 25, etc. These are objections to later traditions and not to the biblical account of the birth of Jesus at all. However, we do need to respond to objections made against the reliability of what we read in the Bible.

Luke’s mistake?

A good example is the historical context of the birth of Jesus. Luke tells us that the birth happened while Augustus Caesar was emperor and during the time of a Roman census when Quirinius was governor of Syria (Luke 2.1-3). Richard Dawkins remarks: ‘Luke screws up his dating by tactlessly mentioning events that historians are capable of independently checking. There was indeed a census … but it happened too late: in AD 6, long after Herod’s death’ (The God Delusion, p.94). Geza Vermes suggests: ‘From whichever angle one looks at it, the census referred to by Luke conflicts with historical reality’ (Nativity: History and Legend, p.86). Marcus Borg and Dominic Crossan, influential New Testament theologians, say that Luke’s account of history is wrong, but then go on to affirm the theological value of his Gospel: ‘What was Luke attempting to say when he got his facts so wrong?’ (The First Christmas, p.148). With theologians like these, who needs Richard Dawkins?

Share
< Previous article| Features| Next article >
Read more articles on:   christmas
Read more articles by Chris Sinkinson >>
Features
The BBC and the Bible

The BBC and the Bible

A new BBC podcast in their “Intrigue” series, called Word of God, deserves a listen – while critical of …

Features
A tiny discovery with  a dramatic impact on  Biblical studies

A tiny discovery with a dramatic impact on Biblical studies

One of the most interesting Israeli archaeologists you could meet is Gabriel Barkay. His archaeological career spans the history of …

Need to advertise?

We can help you reach Christians across the country.

Find out more

Looking for a job?

Browse all our current job adverts

Search